Home / Helical Piles vs Underpinning in Toronto: Which Method Fits

Helical Piles vs Underpinning in Toronto: Which Method Fits

Reviewed November 2026 · Toronto & the GTA

Typical cost$500 – $750per linear foot for underpinning; we do not install or price piles
ResultsEngineer's design decidesrush available
Best forChoosing a foundation method before anyone quotes

Helical piles in Toronto are steel shafts with screw-shaped plates that are turned into the ground until they reach soil that can carry a load. They are a good fit for additions, decks, porches and some settled footings. They do not make a basement taller. If the goal is ceiling height, the methods that deliver it are mass concrete underpinning and a bench footing, and the choice between those two is about floor area and budget.

That is the short version, and it settles most of the calls we get on the subject. Someone has been told by one contractor that piles are the modern answer, by another that underpinning is the only real fix, and they want to know who is right. Usually both are right about a different job. This page sets out the three families of foundation method a Toronto homeowner is likely to hear about, what each one physically does, where each one fits, and what the City asks for before any of them goes in the ground.

We coordinate underpinning and basement lowering projects, the engineer and the permit. We do not install piles and we do not price them. Nobody can tell you which method your house needs, how deep it can go or whether a crack matters until a licensed Ontario engineer has looked at it.

Rather just talk?

(289) 207-6470

Tell us your basement perimeter and current ceiling height and we can give you a realistic range on the call.

  • A firm, itemized price up front
  • Permits and engineering in the number
  • The real timeline, honestly
Call now

Get a real range

Not a brochure. Tell us the basics and we will come back with numbers that reflect your actual foundation.

No obligation. Your details go only to our Toronto team.

Three methods, three different jobs

Every foundation method answers one question: how does the weight of the house get down to soil that can hold it without settling? The answers differ in where that soil is and whether you want the basement floor to move.

Mass concrete underpinning Bench footing Helical piles
What it does Extends the existing foundation deeper, section by section Lowers the middle of the floor and leaves a concrete ledge at the walls Transfers load to deeper soil through steel shafts
Adds basement height Yes, full floor area kept Yes, minus about 18 to 24 inches around the perimeter No, not on its own
Typical Toronto use Basement lowering, legal suites, walkouts Wide basements, rec rooms, tight budgets Additions, decks, porches, sunrooms, some settled footings
What carries the load New concrete footing under the old one The original footing, left in place Helix plates bearing in deeper soil
Our published price $500 to $750 per linear foot Typically 20 to 40 percent less than underpinning We do not price piles
Engineering Sealed design on most Toronto lots, stage testing on every job Drawings required; ask whether your lot needs a sealed design Treated as an engineered system by Ontario municipalities

The rest of this page goes through each column in turn.

Mass concrete underpinning: the method that buys height

Mass concrete underpinning is what most people in Toronto mean when they say "underpinning". The crew digs beneath the existing footing in short sections, pours new concrete under it, lets that section cure and moves on, working in an alternating sequence so that the house is never left sitting over a long open trench. The foundation ends up deeper than it was, and the basement floor can then come down to match.

Because the new footing sits directly under the old wall, the basement keeps its full footprint. That is the whole point of the method and the reason it costs more than the alternatives: more digging by hand, more concrete, more engineering and more inspection. On our published range it runs $500 to $750 per linear foot of foundation wall, and the full line-by-line breakdown is on our page on underpinning cost in Toronto.

The City of Toronto's permit guide for residential underpinning shows how seriously the sequence is taken. The foundation plan has to show the stages of underpinning numbered in the order of work, with the lineal metres of underpinning for those stages, and the distance to and footing depth of adjacent buildings where that applies. A Professional Engineer's design and on-site review is required when the new foundation goes below the footing of an adjacent building and within the angle of repose of the soil, and professional design and field review is also triggered where the underpinning exceeds 1,200 mm of laterally unsupported height or the soil is clay or silt. In every underpinning case, the guide asks for testing and reports by a Professional Engineer during the first and last stages.

If you want a taller basement with every square foot of it usable, mass concrete underpinning is the method that does it.

Our guide to basement lowering in Toronto covers how to measure your basement and how much height to aim for; the underpinning engineer in Toronto page covers what the sealed drawings show and what the engineering line costs.

Bench footing: the cheaper route to the same depth

A bench footing reaches the same new floor level without touching the existing footing. The middle of the basement is excavated, and an angled concrete ledge is formed from the base of the old footing down and inward to the new floor. The original foundation stays exactly where it was.

The trade is simple. A bench typically costs 20 to 40 percent less than full-depth underpinning, and it permanently gives up about 18 to 24 inches of floor around the perimeter. In a wide basement that becomes a rec room or a gym, that ledge barely matters. In a narrow Toronto semi, it can be the difference between a bedroom and a corridor.

Benching still needs a building permit and proper drawings, and whether your lot needs a sealed engineering design depends mostly on how the work relates to a neighbouring building's footings. Our page on benching vs underpinning has the measurement test that settles it, and the benching or underpinning decision tool runs that test on your numbers. Many projects mix the two: underpin the walls where floor area matters and bench the walls where it does not.

Helical piles: what they are and what they are not

A helical pile is a steel shaft with one or more helix-shaped plates welded near the tip. A machine turns it into the ground like a large screw until it reaches soil the design says can carry the load, and the structure above is then connected to the top of the shaft through a cap or a bracket. Related systems you may hear about include push piers, which are driven down using the weight of the structure as the reaction, and micropiles or mini piles, which are drilled and grouted. They all solve the same problem: the soil near the surface is not good enough, so the load is carried down to soil that is.

That makes piles very good at certain jobs:

  • New additions, sunrooms and garages, where a new foundation has to be built and the soil near the surface is soft, fill or wet.
  • Decks and porches, where a pile replaces a poured concrete pier.
  • Stabilising a settled footing, where the engineer decides the problem is a footing bearing on poor soil and the basement height is already fine. Brackets attach to the existing footing and the piles carry it down to better soil.
  • Tight or awkward sites, where a small machine can reach a spot that a crew digging a large pier could not.

And it makes them the wrong tool for one job in particular: lowering a basement. A pile holds the existing footing at the level it already sits. It does not move the footing down, and it does not extend the foundation wall below its current base. To gain basement height you still have to take the floor down past the old footing, and the wall below that point has to be built, which is underpinning or benching work. An engineer can design a lowered basement that uses piles as part of the support, but the piles do not remove the need for the new wall.

The point

Piles answer "what is this footing standing on?". Underpinning answers "how do we make this basement deeper?". They are different questions.

How Ontario municipalities treat helical piles

Helical piles are a proprietary, engineered product, and building departments treat them that way. The City of Toronto's underpinning guide does not mention piles at all, so the requirement for a pile foundation on your project is something to confirm with your engineer and at permit review. As one published example from another Ontario municipality, the City of Barrie's building permit application checklist for decks (dated 26 August 2025) says that if helical piles are used, the applicant must provide a stamped engineer's design, which requires a soil analysis, and a product-specific CCMC report for the conditions of use of the specified product. CCMC is the Canadian Construction Materials Centre, part of the National Research Council, which evaluates construction products.

That is a deck checklist, not an underpinning rule, and Toronto may ask for something different. But it shows the pattern: a pile is only as good as the soil information behind it and the evidence for the specific product, and a building official will want both.

Which method fits your project

The useful way to choose is to start from what you are trying to achieve, not from the method a contractor sells.

Your goal Method that usually fits Why
More ceiling height, full floor area Mass concrete underpinning Only method that deepens the foundation under the existing wall
More ceiling height, wide basement, tighter budget Bench footing, or a hybrid Same depth for less money, if the perimeter ledge is acceptable
A legal basement suite in a narrow house Underpinning A bench can shrink rooms below what a suite needs; see our legal basement apartment guide
A settled corner, height already fine Engineer's call: underpinning or piles Depends on why it settled and what soil is below
A new rear addition on poor soil Often piles or a deeper conventional foundation The new foundation has to reach bearing soil either way
A deck, porch or sunroom Piles or conventional piers Light structures, small loads
A crawl space dug into a full basement Underpinning You are adding depth; see our crawl space to basement conversion page

Two points come up again and again on Toronto houses.

Old foundations change the conversation. Many pre-1920 houses sit on rubble stone or brick footings that were never designed for modern loads. Whether those can take a pile bracket, or need to be underpinned, is an engineering question about that specific wall. Our page on rubble stone foundations in Toronto explains what the engineer looks at.

A settled footing is diagnosed, not sold. If your house has moved, the first step is an engineer's assessment of why. A footing on poor soil, a leaking drain washing fines out, an old addition on a shallow footing and a bowing wall all have different fixes. Our page on foundation repair in Toronto covers how that assessment works and why you want it before any quotes.

What to ask before anyone puts a pile in the ground

If an engineer recommends piles for part of your project, or a pile installer quotes you directly, these questions separate a designed foundation from a product sale:

  1. Is there a stamped design for this lot? It should name the load each pile carries and the soil it has to reach, based on soil information for your site, not a generic chart.
  2. What evaluation exists for the product? Ask whether the specific system has a CCMC evaluation for the way it is being used, and get a copy.
  3. How is each pile accepted? Helical piles are usually installed to a design criterion that the engineer sets. Ask what it is, who records it for each pile and who reviews those records.
  4. Who takes out the permit and books the inspections? On an addition, the piles are part of the addition's permit. Make sure someone owns that.
  5. How does the design deal with the existing house? Where piles meet an old footing, the connection is the part that matters. Ask to see it on the drawings.

The same discipline applies to underpinning quotes. Our guide on how to compare underpinning quotes lists the line items that should be on every one.

Permits and timing in Toronto

Underpinning needs a City of Toronto building permit, and the fee is set per metre of wall: the City's underpinning guide lists $12.37 per linear metre for fees effective January 1, 2026. Engineering on our published range runs $1,500 to $8,000, from a simple design to an adjacent-footing design with site reviews.

The permit itself is rarely the slow part now. In the City's own permit data, the median time from application to issue for underpinning permits applied for in 2025 was 13 days; 43 percent were issued within 10 days and a quarter took 30 days or more. Applications that come back for revisions sit in that slow tail, which is why a complete drawing set matters more than the method. Our underpinning permits by ward page has the full numbers by ward and year, and our guide to underpinning permits in Toronto lists what the package needs.

On site, underpinning typically takes 4 to 6 weeks of work, and benching is usually quicker because there is no sequenced digging under the footing. The engineer's drawings, the soils question and the contractor's calendar usually take longer than the City.

Common questions

Are helical piles cheaper than underpinning?

They are not really comparable, because they do different jobs. Underpinning deepens a foundation so a basement can be lowered; piles carry a load down to better soil without lowering anything. We do not install or price piles. Our published underpinning range is $500 to $750 per linear foot, and a bench footing typically costs 20 to 40 percent less.

Can helical piles lower my basement?

Not on their own. A pile holds an existing footing at the level it already sits. To gain height the floor has to go below the old footing, and the wall below that point has to be built, which is underpinning or benching work.

Do helical piles need an engineer and a permit in Toronto?

Foundation work for a building needs a permit, and Ontario building departments treat helical piles as an engineered system. Barrie's 2025 deck checklist, for example, asks for a stamped engineer's design with a soil analysis and a product-specific CCMC report. Toronto's underpinning guide does not mention piles, so confirm the requirements with your engineer and at permit review.

What is mass concrete underpinning?

It is the traditional method: digging beneath the existing footing in short, alternating sections and pouring new concrete under it, so the foundation ends up deeper and the basement floor can be lowered without losing floor area. Toronto's permit guide asks for those stages to be numbered on the drawings.

What are mini piles or micropiles?

They are small-diameter piles that are drilled and grouted rather than screwed in. Like helical piles, they carry load down to deeper soil and are used for additions, tight sites and some foundation repairs. Like helical piles, they do not make a basement taller.

Can piles fix a settling foundation?

Sometimes. If the engineer finds that a footing is settling because the soil under it is poor and the basement height is not an issue, piles can carry that footing down to better soil. If you also want height, or the cause is something else, underpinning or another repair may be the answer. Get the engineer's assessment before any quotes.

How long does an underpinning permit take in Toronto?

In the City's permit data, the median time from application to issue for underpinning permits applied for in 2025 was 13 days, with a quarter taking 30 days or more. Incomplete drawings are the usual reason an application lands in the slow tail.

Call (289) 207-6470 with your address, the rough size of your basement and what you want the space to become, or send the details below. We will tell you which method your project is likely to involve and what the engineer will need to see first.

Rather just talk?

(289) 207-6470

Tell us your basement perimeter and current ceiling height and we can give you a realistic range on the call.

  • A firm, itemized price up front
  • Permits and engineering in the number
  • The real timeline, honestly
Call now

Get a real range

Not a brochure. Tell us the basics and we will come back with numbers that reflect your actual foundation.

No obligation. Your details go only to our Toronto team.

Know the number before you dig.

Tell us your perimeter and current height. We will give you a realistic range, not a brochure.

Call (289) 207-6470
Call nowGet a range